A good Friday
Author: Berry Bros. & Rudd
Our last day of our Bordeaux 2009 en primeur week was spent in the Graves – a 9am start at Ch. la Mission Haut-Brion, tasting both Haut-Brion and La Mission.
We’d already been mentally preparing our taste buds for the final First Growth of the Médoc. Ch. Haut-Brion was fabulous, showing subtle red fruit aromas and an expressive palate with ripe tannins, glorious depth and resounding flavours. We felt however that it was pipped to the post by La Mission’s deep black cherry and cassis aromas, gorgeous texture and fine precision, all balanced perfectly within a framework of elegance.
Our next stop was an exciting new property for us. Ch. les Carmes Haut-Brion is a 4-hectare only property whose vineyard is also overshadowed by the rather prosaic water tower that marks the end of Ch. Haut-Brion’s territory (above). This was a great find – a truly lovely wine with silky, succulent fruit and wonderful sophistication, thanks to the unusually high proportion (30%) of Cabernet Franc in the blend. This is most definitely a property to watch. Here is a video we took of Penelope Furt from the Château:
So, with only Domaine de Chevalier and Ch. Haut-Bailly to go, it was already turning out to be a good Friday.
Domaine de Chevalier’s red Grand Vin was stunning. Opulent, seductive, silky, succulent and wonderfully balanced – a true star of the vintage (see us below arriving at the Château). We believe it’s better than its brilliant 05. Surely it could not get better than this, we thought. We were about to be proved wrong.
Veronique Sanders of Ch. Haut-Bailly has surpassed herself this year with an absolutely magical wine. Not since tasting Ch. Latour on Wednesday have we had the same frisson of being in the presence of something uniquely special. Succulent yet so elegant, there is a feminine touch to the ’09 Haut-Bailly that lifts it way above its usual (already high) standards. Better than the 2005, this is a wine to rival all the ‘super seconds’ and a couple of the firsts; an utterly wonderful way to finish the week.
So, what is our verdict on 2009? It does seem that, by chance, we chose the best order in which to taste the communes this year, with each day building upwards from the last.
The hallmark of the vintage seems to be an extraordinary high level of fine but very ripe tannins, offset by an amazing freshness – a vintage therefore for the Cabernets to shine. The Right Bank had some greats but was inconsistent overall with some of the Merlots being overripe and alcoholic. The truly great wines of the vintage are certainly centered in the four main communes of the Médoc, with consistent high quality and some truly magnificent, ethereal wines – especially at the level of the First Growths.
We will go back and take time to reflect on the wines we have tasted while our teams who look after our private clients from the UK and from Hong Kong also head to the South West over the next couple of weeks to add their opinions to ours. It’s been an amazing experience, and the campaign hasn’t even begun yet. Right now, we feel drained, euphoric and very excited about the forthcoming months. It’s not going to be fast, pretty or cheap but we’ll keep you posted every step of the way.
Finally, we’ll leave you with a video of Simon Staples, Alun Griffiths MW and Nick Pegna from this week’s team, discussing their thoughts of the 2009s so far…
$64m question – Any indications about pricing?
How would you going to mananging the allocation?? Definitely more must have wines on my list now, bit of worried if i could gets them all. As i heard i might needs to buy boardly from top to bottom by rewarding with more allocaitons of 1st growth. Ta
As 2009 seems to be getting rave reviews I presume that means prices will be high for the bigger names and better wines.
Any thoughts on the 2nd wines, are they worth buying, are both quality and price ok?
Cheers
James
Just to correct about chateau Les Carmes Haut-Brion it’s 30% of cabernet franc and just 15% of cabernet sauvignon.
The cabernet franc it’s in big proportion in this wine and make it beautifully elegant.
Thank you very much, we have amended this in the post. Apologies for our error.
Jake, Mike and James, Simon Staples is writing a post-Bordeaux blog so he’ll discuss these vital questions in that…he’ll have it up later this week.
Hi James,
It’s not going to be cheap but I know we’ll be able to get you value out of the vintage. Have a look at this section on our site:
http://www.bbr.com/fine-wine/bordeaux09-best-buys
Second wines of the big boys will be more expensive and less good I fear.
Simon