Grape or place on the label?
Author: Berry Bros. & Rudd
The red wines from Chinon and Bourgueil are made from Cabernet Franc but they don’t often say so: the names of the area and the grower are prominent. Today, the wine laws allow the label to name the grape as well. Until recently, it was actually forbidden for most Appellation d’Origine Contrôlée (AOC) wines, but it is still not common.
The reason for this is buried deep in the French wine laws. The whole point of the laws is to defend authenticity. The wine producer needs protection against fraudulent use of his or her identity. As everywhere, the law comes down hard on those who pretend their wine is someone else’s – stealing the ID of, say, Château X.
In France (and nearly all wine countries have followed France down this road) the law goes further. It recognises that Bourgueil, for example, is a valuable name: wine from there is highly thought-of, and the name on the label commands a higher price than wine from lesser villages. A wine from Bourgueil must, if it is to carry the coveted name, stick to the rules as laid down in the AOC regulations. This of course protects the consumer as well as the producer.
The main points the French rules cover are:
- Origin: the grapes must be from a specific area
- Grapes: each AOC sets out which varieties can be grown, and all others are forbidden
- Yield: only so much wine can be made from each hectare of vines
- Vintage: 85 per cent of the wine must come from the year stated
Many AOC rules go further into details like pruning, picking dates and bottling. Some wine zones also taste and appraise wines. But the big four are those noted above.
So you can be pretty certain that a French wine with AOC/Appellation Contrôlée on the label is what it says it is. And that the grapes are grown, and the wine made, to an approved “recipe”.
Broadly put, an AOC guarantees origin, not quality. The reputation of the producer is all-important: within the rules, there’s wide scope for some winemakers to make splendid wine and others to turn out boring, indifferent bottles. Both will have the appellation on the label, but within every appellation some vineyards are better than others – and the bigger the wine zone the wider the variation.
The law sets the minimum standards: it does not – cannot – guarantee excellence. Finding that is down to you the consumer and your wine merchant.
Who made the rules?
The Italians, more particularly the Tuscans, say they thought of it first… In 1716 the Duke of Tuscany made a law stating which villages Chianti could come from. The list of top vineyards in Tokaji, Hungary, dates from a royal decree of 1737. In Portugal, lawmakers set out the borders of the Port country in 1756. French wine districts began to define their zones at the end of the 19th century, and the French national AOC system dates from 1935.
… and how to get round them
Does authentic mean old-fashioned? Critics of the French (and other nations’) quality-wine systems complain that the rules set wines in stone: you have to make your wine the way your grandfather did, and experiments with new grapes or techniques are forbidden. In truth, there are ways for a freethinking winemaker to sidestep the rules – for instance by “demoting” their wines to the lesser, but freer, quality level formerly known as Vins de Pays (in modern Euro-speak, Indication Géographique Protégée or IGP) and build a reputation unfettered by the terms of the local AOC.
These acronyms can get confusing…
AOP – Appellation d’Origine Protégée – is the updated term for AOC in the 2009 European Union wine law reforms. You’ll see either AOP or AOC on the label.
IGP – Indication Géographique Protégée – replaces Vin de Pays.